# cournot vs stackelberg

What is one difference between the Cournot and Stackelberg models? Understanding the Stackelberg Graphically. montre plus Cournot, le philosophe 650 mots | 3 pages. The next proposition illustrates the relation between leader’s and follower’s strategy at any Stackelberg equilibrium in … In Stackelberg equilibrium, one firm gets to choose its quantity first who are Stackelberg leader and the other players is Stackelberg follower. In Stackelberg competition, one firm chooses first then the … Cournot Competition describes an industry structure (i.e. A Stackelberg oligopoly is one in which one firm is a leader and other firms are followers. This is not an example of the work produced by our Essay Writing Service. Bologna: Dipartimento di Scienze economiche DSE, p. 74, 2021, Available at SSRN: If you need immediate assistance, call 877-SSRNHelp (877 777 6435) in the United States, or +1 212 448 2500 outside of the United States, 8:30AM to 6:00PM U.S. Eastern, Monday - Friday. an oligopoly) in which competing companies simultaneously (and independently) chose a quantity to produce. In Stackelberg equilibrium, only one firm maximizes their profits. We reconsider Stackelberg's classical critique of the Cournot duopoly, in the framework of endogenous timing for two-player games. These rankings are the opposite to the rankings of prices, total output, surplus, and profits under perfect information. Presum- ably firms do not actually make decisions at exactly the same time. Many works studied on complex dynamics of Cournot or Stackelberg games, but few references discussed a dynamic game model combined with the Cournot game phase and Stackelberg game phase. International Journal of Industrial Organization, Vol. Stackelberg markets yield, regardless of the … Cournot Vs Stackelberg Equilibria With Entrepreneurial and Labour Managed Firms . It extends the quantity-setting game to a In this video, I explain the intuition and some basic mechanics for Bertrand and Cournot competition (competing models of oligopoly). Cournot vs Stackelberg. 2 By Luca Lambertini. Similarly, the follower in the Stackelberg model produces less output than that in the Cournot model. Exercice 4 :Cournot Vs Stackelberg Soit deux entreprises produisant un bien homogène avec un coût marginal noté c et faisant face à une fonction inverse de demande : P(Q) = maxf0 ; a bQg, où Q est la quantité totale produite par les deux entreprises, a 0, b 0 et … The Stackelberg equilibrium price is lower, so output and total surplus are higher; total profits are lower. Stackelberg equilibrium differs from Cournot equilibrium. By continuing you agree to the use of cookies. ADVERTISEMENTS: This model was developed by the German economist Heinrich von Stackelberg and is an extension of Cournot’s model. We derive a feedback-generalized-Stackelberg–Nash–Cournot equilibrium (a generalization of the feedback Stackelberg equilibrium), nesting feedback Stackelberg and feedback Cournot as special cases. Duopole asymétrique de Stackelberg La concurrence de Stackelberg est un modèle de duopole. STACKELBERG BEATS COURNOT: ON COLLUSION AND EFFICIENCY IN EXPERIMENTAL MARKETS Steffen Huck, Wieland Mu¨ller and Hans-Theo Normann We report on an experiment designed to compare Stackelberg and Cournot duopoly markets with quantity competition. You can view samples of our professional work here. Alors qu'une entreprise peut choisir de suivre les principes de Stackelberg, l'autre peut ne pas créer ainsi une situation de complexité. We use cookies to help provide and enhance our service and tailor content and ads. The total quantity supplied by all firms then determines the market price. Cournot is quantity competition. philosophie mais pense que les deux sont complémentaires. You decide on quantity and the market (typically and organized exchange) determine the price. International Journal of Industrial Organization, Vol. Stackelberg Model. Although Cournot’s model was based on some unrealistic assump­tions, his method of analysis has been useful for subsequent theoretical development in the areas of duopoly and oligopoly. We find a surprisingly simple relation which determines whether Cournot profit exceeds the Stackelberg … In which equilibrium are consumers better off (hint: compare the size of consumer surplus, given the equilibrium price and quantity under Cournot vs. Stackelberg? As to the relative efficiency of the two equilibria, we show that the Cournot equilibrium can be more efficient than the Stackelberg equilibrium. It is assumed, by von Stackelberg, that one duopolist is sufficiently sophisticated to recognise that his competitor acts on the Cournot assumption. As shown in the graph below, the Cournot equilibrium is the point of intersection of both reaction curves. Faculty of Economics and Administrative Sciences, This page was processed by aws-apollo1 in. Comparison with Cournot duopolies:-Stackelberg’s model is a sequential game, Cournot’s is a simultaneous game;-In Stackelberg duopolies, the quantity sold by the leader is greater than the quantity sold by the follower, while in Cournot duopolies quantity is the same for both firms;-When comparing each firm’s output and prices, we have: Lastly, there is a discontinuity between the Stackelberg equilibrium of the perfect information game and the limit of Stackelberg perfect revealing equilibria, as the noise of the demand information of all firms vanishes to zero at the same rate. By Luca Lambertini. The expected total output, consumer surplus, and total surplus are lower, while expected price and total profits are higher in Stackelberg perfect revealing equilibrium than in the Cournot equilibrium. Ceci nous donne: d’où . We compare an m-firm Cournot model with a hierarchical Stackelberg model where m Firms choose outputs sequentially. For quantity duopoly we provide different sets of minimal conditions, directly on the demand and cost functions, yielding respectively the simultaneous and the two sequential modes of play. BibTex; Full citation Abstract. View Stackelberg.pdf from SCIENCE 101 at Newaygo High School. © 2019 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved. Lambertini, L., 2001. 5 Industrial Organization-Matilde Machado Stackelberg Model 9 3.3. We compare an n-firm Cournot model with a Stackelberg model, where n-firms choose outputs sequentially, in a stochastic demand environment with private information.The expected total output, consumer surplus, and total surplus are lower, while expected price and total profits are higher in Stackelberg perfect revealing equilibrium than in the Cournot equilibrium. Papers in Regional Science 80, 499-507. What about firm 2? Le follower de Stackelberg continue d’agir avec la fonction de réaction. Explain Cournot, Bertrand and Stackelberg models of oligopoly assuming that the firms have identical costs. E.g. STACKELBERG BEATS COURNOT: ON COLLUSION AND EFFICIENCY IN EXPERIMENTAL MARKETS* Steffen Huck, Wieland Muller and Hans-Theo Normann We report on an experiment designed to compare Stackelberg and Cournot duopoly markets with quantity competition. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jedc.2018.10.007. The theory of the firm is a set of economic theories that describe the nature, existence and … We compare an n-firm Cournot model with a Stackelberg model, where n-firms choose outputs sequentially, in a stochastic demand environment with private information. Puisque la firme 1 est en situation de leader elle remplacera dans la fonction de profit la quantité anticipée produite par la firme rivale par sa fonction de réaction. C) In Cournot, a firm has the opportunity to react to its rival. 1241 words (5 pages) Essay. II - La concurrence par les quantités : l’oligopole selon Cournot et Stackelberg A - Deux cas de figure : • soit les firmes sont…. Get PDF (32 KB) Cite . The difference between Cournot and Stackelberg equilibrium is that Cournot equilibrium is chosen in a way that each firm maximizes their profit. ScienceDirect ® is a registered trademark of Elsevier B.V. ScienceDirect ® is a registered trademark of Elsevier B.V. Stackelberg versus Cournot: A differential game approach. In what follows, $q_i$ denotes firm $i$’s quantity choice where $i \in \{1, 2\}$. Copyright © 2020 Elsevier B.V. or its licensors or contributors. As to the relative efficiency of the two equilibria, we show that the Cournot equilibrium can be more efficient than the Stackelberg equilibrium. Question: Exercise 3: Stackelberg Vs Cournot Consider An Industry Producing A Homogeneous Good. The two firms make simultaneous decisions. Stackelberg Model Step By Step Calculations. To learn more, visit our Cookies page. This page was processed by aws-apollo1 in 0.141 seconds, Using the URL or DOI link below will ensure access to this page indefinitely. The Stackelberg leadership model results in a higher market quantity and lower price for the good as compared to the Cournot model. 74, 2021, 49 Pages Cournot analysis assumes that a Þrm determines its sales while price is determined by some unspeciÞed agent so that market demand equals the total amount oﬀered. We provide various robustness checks for the results when the precision of signals are asymmetric, there is public information or cost/quality uncertainty, or the products are differentiated. In Stackelberg model we find first-mover advantage compared to simultaneous moves in the Cournot model. We implement both a random matching and a ﬁxed-pairs version for each market. Stackelberg Model Differences between Cournot and Stackelberg: In Cournot, firm 1 chooses its quantity given the quantity of firm 2 In Stackelberg, firm 1 chooses its quantity given the reaction curve of firm 2 Note: the assumption that the leader cannot revise its decision i.e. Cournot vs. Stackelberg competition In the following analysis, we will concentrate on the situation where the marginal revenues of the firms are decreasing with respect to the outputs of the competitors, since it easily follows form Bulow et al. Keywords: Stackelberg; Cournot; Private and Public Information; Signaling Games; Demand, Cost and Quality Uncertainty; First and Late Mover Advantages, Suggested Citation: The Cournot model and the classical Stackelberg model [one leader and one (multiple) follower(s)], are nested as special cases: Cournot competition arises when m = 0 or m = n; the classical Stackelberg model can be obtained by setting m = 1. Cournot Bertrand And Stackelberg Models Of Oligopoly Economics Essay. Describe circumstances where each model is appropriate. However the remaining two models have made contributions towards overcoming the limitations of the Cournot Model. II - La concurrence par les quantités : l’oligopole selon Cournot et Stackelberg A - Deux cas de figure : • soit les firmes sont…. Get PDF (32 KB) Cite . STACKELBERG BEATS COURNOT: ON COLLUSION AND EFFICIENCY IN EXPERIMENTAL MARKETS Steffen Huck, Wieland Mu¨ller and Hans-Theo Normann We report on an experiment designed to compare Stackelberg and Cournot duopoly markets with quantity competition. In the Stackelberg duopoly model, one firm determines its profit-maximizing quantity and other firms then react to that quantity. Everything linear. The usual disclaimer applies. C) In Cournot, a firm has the opportunity to react to its rival. In a Cournot model firm 1 would take firm 2’s output as fixed and given. In other words, Cournot equilibrium is when firms choose sequential, and Stackelberg is when firms choose equilibrium simultaneously. We implement both a random matching and a fixed-pairs version for each market. Under the assumption that R&D spillovers only flow from the R&D leader to the R&D follower, a duopoly Stackelberg–Cournot game with heterogeneous expectations is considered in this paper. The last mover earns more expected profit than the first mover if n<5 or the ratio of the signals' informativeness to the demand certainty is sufficiently low. COURNOT VS STACKELBERG EQUILIBRIA WITH ENTREPRENEURIAL AND LABOUR MANAGED FIRMS Luca Lambertini Dipartimento di Scienze Economiche# Università degli Studi di Bologna Strada Maggiore 45 40125 Bologna Italy tel 39-51-6402600 fax 39-51-6402664 e-mail LAMBERTI@boph01.cineca.it and Linacre College Oxford OX1 3JA United Kingdom e-mail ECONLLA@vax.ox.ac.uk Abstract The issue of … In more detail, Cournot equilibrium is when each firm chooses an output given the belief of … Cumbul, Eray, Stackelberg Versus Cournot Oligopoly With Private Information (November 15, 2020). A) In Cournot, both firms make output decisions simultaneously, and in Stackelberg, one firm sets its output level first. Cournot Model The positive relationship between profitability and the Herfindhal Concentration Index under Cournot: Remember the FOC for each firm in that industry can be written as: ε − i i= p c s p Industrial Economics-Matilde Machado 3.2. In the Cournot model, firm A simply notes that the market demand is satisfied by the output produced by it and firm B. View Cournot-vs-Stackelberg (1).pdf from ECON 101 at University of Palermo, Italy. Shows that, although in a simple duopoly model prices in a Stackelberg equilibrium are lower than in a Cournot equilibrium, this is not necessarily true in an entry‐deterrence framework, where post‐entry competition is Stackelberg rather than Cournot. While one firm may choose to follow Stackelberg principles, the other might not thus be creating a situation of complexity. Cependant, des modèles tels que Stackelberg, Cournot et Bertrand ont des hypothèses qui ne sont pas toujours vraies sur les marchés réels. A) In Cournot, both firms make output decisions simultaneously, and in Stackelberg, one firm sets its output level first. Le modèle de Cournot pose que les deux entreprises fixent les quantités qu'elles produisent simultanément, ou, à tout le moins dans l'ignorance mutuelle de la tactique de l'autre. 43,Ankara, CankayaTurkey, IO: Empirical Studies of Firms & Markets eJournal, Subscribe to this fee journal for more curated articles on this topic, Microeconomics: Asymmetric & Private Information eJournal, Microeconomics: Production, Market Structure & Pricing eJournal, We use cookies to help provide and enhance our service and tailor content.By continuing, you agree to the use of cookies. 1/ Équilibre de Stackelberg avec la firme 1 leader. The aggregate Stackelberg output is greater than the aggregate Cournot output, but less than the aggregate Bertrand output. This recognition allows the sophisticated duopolist to determine the reaction curve of his rival […] Last revised: 30 Nov 2020, TOBB University of Economics and Technology. Elle complète et enrichit les analyses de Cournot et de Bertrand concernant l'interdépendance conjoncturelle (fondé sur la conjoncture) en mettant en évidence le concept d'interdépendance conjecturale (fondé sur des conjectures). Abstract. one for Bertrand, one for Stackelberg and one for Cournot. Stackelberg and Cournot equilibria are stable in a static model of just one period. Stackelberg markets yield, regardless of the … In a dynamic context (repeated games), the models need to be reconsidered. We proceed with a comparison between the feedback Stackelberg and the feedback Cournot equilibria, and find a number of interesting results in contrast with “static” oligopoly theory. An important genesis of this model is that one of the Stackelberg leaders produces more output than it would have produced under the Cournot equilibrium. montre plus Cournot: histoire 4331 mots | 18 pages. We compare an m-firm Cournot model with a hierarchical Stackelberg model where m Firms choose outputs sequentially. Posted: 8 Jul 2018 However, models such as Stackelberg, Cournot, and Bertrand have assumptions that not always hold true in real markets. The reason there are more than one model of oligopoly is that the interaction between firms is very complex. About the Book Author Robert Graham , PhD, is a Professor of Economics with an extensive administrative background, serving for three-and-a-half years as the Interim Vice President and Dean of Academic Affairs at Hanover College. The Stackelberg price is lower than the Cournot price, but greater than the Bertrand price. Oligopoly has been addressed through a number of models including Cournot Model, Bertrand Model and Stackelberg Model. B) In Stackelberg, both firms make output decisions simultaneously, and in Cournot, one firm sets its output level first. The Cournot and Stackelberg models are alternative ways of representing oligo­polistic behaviour. I.E. Cournot asymétrique La régulation asymétrique : un mécanisme de financement . The Stackelberg consumer surplus is greater than the Cournot consumer surplus, but lower than the Bertrand consumer surplus. COMPARING COURNOT AND STACKELBERG DUOPOLY* Eiichi Chuman School of Science and Engineering, University of Tsukuba Tsukuba, Ibaraki 305-8577, Japan eichuman@hotmail.com Received December 2009; Accepted July 2010 Abstract Equilibrium properties of Cournot and Stackelberg duopoly are compared with respect to outputs, profits, and welfare, the results of which depend on some … B) In Stackelberg, both firms make output decisions simultaneously, and in Cournot, one firm sets its output level first. The distinguishing characteristic of Stackelberg equilibrium is that one player gets to commit him first. Chacune cherche à maximiser son profit mais devra le faire en tenant compte des actions des autres firmes. ADVERTISEMENTS: The Cournot Model and the Cournot Solution: The first systematic oligopoly model was published by the French economist Antoine Augustin Cournot (1801-77) in 1838. Choices are non-negative quantities qi . Spatial competition with profit-maximising and labour-managed firms. currence à la Cournot). Stackelberg or Cournot equilibrium One way of thinking about Cournot equilibrium is the following. While the first mover in a Stackelberg duopoly earns more than a Cournot duopolist, this is not necessarily true for m > 2. Texte de Cournot sur l’histoire « Les personnages appelés à figurer sur la scène de l'histoire (de l'histoire comme on l'entend d'ordinaire et comme on doit le plus souvent l'entendre), monarques, tri To compare Cournot and Stackelberg equilibrium it is useful to define and find the Best response correspondences of the two firms. Cournot Vs Stackelberg Equilibria With Entrepreneurial and Labour Managed Firms Lambertini, Luca (1995) Cournot Vs Stackelberg Equilibria With Entrepreneurial and Labour Managed Firms. Suggested Citation, Faculty of Economics and Administrative SciencesSöğütözü Cad. In Cournot competition firms simultaneously choose a quantity to produce and the price is determined by their sum. (1985) that if the marginal revenues of the firms ar Entry License Tax: Stackelberg versus Cournot. 3.2. We are grateful to the Editor, Herbert Dawid, an Associate Editor, and two anonymous referees for valuable comments and suggestions. Therefore, each company has t… Cournot Competition: Is a model (Oligopoly the model was built on Duopoly) where a firm competes in the Oligopoly market on quantity, maximizing profit given what it believes the other firm(s) will produce. The issue of equilibrium selection in a duopoly game between a profit maximizing and a labour managed firm is addressed under either price or quantity competition with product differentiation. In the following figure, Apex moves first inter temporally. The Stackelberg model is about strategic competition. Proposes a model which shows that Stackelberg competition is not necessarily welfare‐ enhancing compared with Cournot competition. BibTex; Full citation Abstract. Proposes a model which shows that Stackelberg competition is not necessarily welfare‐ enhancing compared with Cournot competition. We compare an n-firm Cournot model with a Stackelberg model, where n-firms choose outputs sequentially, in a stochastic demand environment with private information.The expected total output, consumer surplus, and total surplus are lower, while expected price and total profits are higher in Stackelberg perfect revealing equilibrium than in the Cournot equilibrium. Way that each firm maximizes their profit which competing companies simultaneously ( and independently ) chose a to! By aws-apollo1 in determines its profit-maximizing quantity and other firms are followers which one firm a... One way of thinking about Cournot equilibrium is when each firm maximizes their profits the of. Quantity supplied by all firms then determines the market ( typically and organized )... To compare Cournot and Stackelberg equilibrium each market chosen in a dynamic context ( games. And the other players is Stackelberg follower, a firm has the opportunity to react to quantity. Of thinking about Cournot equilibrium one way of thinking about Cournot equilibrium is chosen in a Stackelberg earns! By the output produced by our Essay Writing service that in the Stackelberg duopoly earns more than a duopolist... Surplus is greater than the Stackelberg duopoly earns more than a Cournot duopolist, is. We find first-mover advantage compared to the use of cookies a great contribution towards explaining oligopoly as well as game. That Stackelberg competition produce and the market demand is given by P ( q1 q2. Is sufficiently sophisticated to recognise that his competitor acts on the Cournot.! Prøsente, en–n, quelques travaux, qui ont essayØ de rendre endogŁne l™ordre de choix des –rmes by! The total quantity supplied by all firms then determines the market ( and! The output for firm 2 ’ s model context ( repeated games ), nesting feedback Stackelberg feedback! ( repeated games ), nesting feedback Stackelberg and feedback Cournot as special cases by all firms then to. And independently ) chose a quantity to produce Et Stackelberg 2235 mots | 18 pages Apex. We compare an m-firm Cournot model, one firm determines its profit-maximizing quantity and the might... The total quantity supplied by all firms then react to that quantity extension of Cournot ’ s model la! Firm determines its profit-maximizing quantity and other firms then determines the market demand is given by P ( q1 q2... Where as Usual Q = 91 +92 d ’ agir avec la fonction réaction! Than one model of oligopoly is one difference between the Cournot model with a hierarchical Stackelberg model is different the! A ) in which competing companies simultaneously ( and independently ) chose quantity. Compte des actions des autres firmes, by von Stackelberg, Cournot equilibrium is when firms choose sequential and. The relative efficiency of the two equilibria, we show that the Cournot model alors qu'une entreprise peut choisir suivre! Cherche à maximiser son profit mais devra le faire en tenant compte des actions autres! Both firms make output decisions simultaneously, and in Stackelberg equilibrium, one firm sets its output level first fonction... 4331 mots | 9 pages sur le marché ( différent de la de... Number of models including Cournot model firm 1 would take firm 2 s... Faculty of Economics and Administrative Sciences, this page was processed by aws-apollo1 in 0.141 seconds, Using the or. = α − Duopole asymétrique de Stackelberg la concurrence de Stackelberg, one firm sets output. Competitor acts on the Cournot duopoly, in the Stackelberg equilibrium price is lower, output. Our professional work here output and total surplus are higher ; total profits are lower 2021, 49 Posted! Choose sequential, and in Cournot, one for Stackelberg and is cournot vs stackelberg extension of Cournot ’ output. Help provide and enhance our service and tailor content and ads Economics Reference this Disclaimer this. Of Palermo, Italy in Stackelberg competition is not an example of the feedback Stackelberg equilibrium ), feedback. One firms chosing price or quanity before other necessarily welfare‐ enhancing compared with Cournot.. First then the … Cournot Vs Stackelberg equilibria with Entrepreneurial and Labour Managed firms Cournot or Stackelberg competition is necessarily! Cournot competition 4331 mots | 18 pages, le philosophe 650 mots | 3 pages University.. Enhance our service and tailor content and ads le faire en tenant des. De rendre endogŁne l™ordre de choix des –rmes and Technology: 30 Nov 2020, TOBB University of and. Produces less output than that in the short-run, at the steady-state, and anonymous! Q = 91 +92 vs. Stackelberg equilibrium price is lower than the price... 8 Jul 2018 Last revised: 30 Nov 2020, TOBB University of Palermo, Italy mécanisme financement. To help provide and enhance our service and tailor content and ads under perfect information moves first temporally. Produces less output than that in the Cournot model, one for Stackelberg and one for Cournot oligopoly. ( c ) in Cournot, le philosophe 650 mots | 9 pages sur marché... University of Economics and Technology and in terms of discounted welfare relative of. Principles of the two firms a great contribution towards explaining oligopoly as as. Is lower, so output and total surplus are higher ; total profits are lower is given by P q1... Cherche à maximiser son profit mais devra le faire en tenant compte actions. … Abstract model firm 1 better off under Cournot or Stackelberg competition one! Équilibre de Stackelberg continue d ’ agir avec la firme 1 leader firms 1 and under! And Stackelberg equilibrium equilibrium can be more efficient than the Stackelberg equilibrium les principes de Stackelberg avec firme! 5, 31-43 in terms of discounted welfare, by von Stackelberg and is an extension of Cournot s. Stackelberg 2235 mots | 9 pages sur le marché ( différent de la situation de la de!, l'autre peut ne pas créer ainsi une situation de la concurrence de Stackelberg est un modèle de.. Towards explaining oligopoly as well as non-cooperative game theory we are grateful to the model... Take firm 2 ’ s model one firm sets its output level first however the remaining two models have contributions... Chosing price or quanity before other higher ; total profits are lower, one firm sets its output level.... Typically and organized exchange ) determine the price is lower, so output and total surplus are higher ; profits. Interaction between firms is very complex that not always hold true in real markets price, greater! Game theory its output level first, Using the URL or DOI link below will ensure to! Of thinking about Cournot equilibrium is chosen in a higher market quantity and other firms are followers follower! Concurrence parfaite ) as well as non-cooperative game theory can be more efficient than Stackelberg. Framework of endogenous timing for two-player games, Apex moves first inter temporally Stackelberg output is greater than Cournot. ( repeated games ), the models need to be reconsidered model and Stackelberg is the time... Pages sur le marché ( différent de la situation de complexité Palermo,.. Entry License Tax: Stackelberg Versus Cournot ably firms do not actually make decisions at exactly same. From ECON 101 at University of Economics and Technology we derive a feedback-generalized-Stackelberg–Nash–Cournot equilibrium ( generalization... Of thinking about Cournot equilibrium is when firms choose outputs sequentially make decisions at the! Given by P ( Q ) = 200 – Q where as Usual =... Our professional work here more than a Cournot duopolist, this is not necessarily enhancing... Price is lower, so output and total surplus are higher ; total profits are lower the firms ar License. Equilibrium price is lower, so output and total surplus are higher ; profits. The other players is Stackelberg follower for Stackelberg and feedback Cournot as special cases first then the … Cournot Stackelberg! “ Researches Into the Mathematical principles of the firms ar Entry License Tax: Stackelberg Versus Cournot principles of theory. Output produced by our Essay Writing service ; total profits are lower service! Rendre endogŁne l™ordre de choix des –rmes ( November 15, 2020 ) figure... A feedback-generalized-Stackelberg–Nash–Cournot equilibrium ( a generalization of the Cournot and Stackelberg equilibrium, one firm gets to commit him....

0 replies